Everyone who wishes to take part. There is nothing to sign up for and no one to ask. The minyan is not attached to any synagogue, movement or organisation. It is a room that opens three times a day, and you are welcome in it whether you come every morning or only once. Nitzavim is the parsha in which everyone stands together, and its list runs all the way down to the woodcutter and the water-drawer. The name is meant literally.

קולנו, Kolenu, means “our voice”, and its gematria is 192. נצבים, Nitzavim, is the parsha that opens “you are standing here today, all of you”. The three words that come to 192 are set out on the front page.

Open the front page and you will find the next service at the top, with the time remaining until it begins. Tap the button and you are in. If the service has already started, the button stays there until it ends, so arriving late is perfectly normal. The site does not ask for your name and keeps no account for you.

The service follows the Patah Eliyahu siddur. You can download the texts for Shacharit and Arvit as a PDF (65 pages, 0.5 MB) to follow along on your screen or print at home.

If you have a question about how the minyan works, Frank answers the ones people ask most below.

There is no service on Shabbat or on festivals. When a service is cancelled for a particular day, for a yom tov or for any other reason, it remains on the front page, struck through, with the reason beside it. You will never be left to work it out from a gap.

If you would like to be told of changes, or to ask a question before you come, please feel free to join the WhatsApp community or to write to us.

Frank answers the questions people ask most, in his own words. Tap a question to read his answer.

Are you a rabbi, or religiously trained?

No. I am neither a rabbi, nor do I have any religious training. I am simply someone who usually leads the service, and I wanted to be able to run a minyan online.

Why did you start it?

My father died about a year and a half ago, and there was no way for me to say Kaddish. I found a really great website, Live Minyan, from Sephardic U, which was doing exactly that, and I said Kaddish with them. The only difficulty was that they are based in the United States, so the times of the morning and afternoon prayers were not right for us here. So I came up with the idea of holding one at the proper hours for this time zone.

I hope that every time zone in the world will one day have its own minyan, whether it is connected to this one, to the one in the United States, or to neither. That makes no difference. The only thing that matters is that anyone who wants to attend a service can do so, at any time.

Do you guarantee a minyan three times a day, every day?

No, we do not. We cannot guarantee that there will be a minyan, but we will always endeavour to hold the service. If there is no minyan, we still hold it, but we leave out the parts that cannot be recited without one.

Do I need to be Jewish to attend a service?

Everyone is welcome, Jewish or not. Naturally, the service is designed for Jewish people who wish to follow the Jewish ritual, but we welcome anybody. The only point is that only Jewish people are counted in the minyan.

Do you accept women, and do you count them in the minyan?

We accept women, as we accept anybody. Do we count women in the minyan? Yes, if they are Jewish, of course. That is our position.

We are preparing a paper on the subject. Our view is that there is nothing in the Torah, or in the Talmud or the Gemara, forbidding a woman to be counted in a minyan. The interpretations excluding women from the minyan came afterwards. Our view today is that women should be counted.

Do you hold a service on Shabbat and Yom Tov?

For the time being, no. But we are seriously considering holding a service on Shabbat and Yom Tov. We believe that it is possible under certain circumstances, and we base our position on the writing of a rabbi who explains why, and under which circumstances, the use of electricity is possible during Shabbat. For the time being, however, we hold services on weekdays only, and not on Shabbat or Yom Tov.

Can I join the minyan if I am outside this time zone?

Yes, of course. There is no restriction on that. The only thing we would say is that we believe the morning, afternoon and evening services should be said at the proper times, based on your own time. However, everybody is free to attend, and if you wish to put on your tefillin or say the prayers with us, even if it is not exactly the right time for you, you are more than welcome to do so.

We consider that we can hold a proper service when there are at least ten people, a full minyan, in the relevant time zone. If there are not, we may rely on a rule of six plus four: at least six people in the relevant time zone, plus at least four who are not in it but have already fulfilled their obligation. This is becoming a little complex, but we are trying to depart from halakha as little as possible, and to innovate, or be progressive, only where it is absolutely necessary.

Are you starting a new religion?

No, not at all. We are not starting a new religion. We stay within mainstream Judaism, and we follow the traditional ritual. We are perhaps a little more innovative in our use of online media, but that is about it.

On Shabbat, we believe, based on the work of the rabbi I mentioned above, that we can hold a service. But we still make sure, as much as possible, that we have, if I may use the expression, a legal basis in halakha. What we are changing is perhaps a more modern, more contemporary interpretation than the ones that were made 200, 500 or 1,000 years ago. That is really our approach.

So no new religion, and we are neither liberal nor orthodox. We are simply trying to offer the service, because the reality is that a lot of people would like to attend, whatever their level of practice, simply because they want to. And we do not see why we should not do that.

What happens if you are not available?

If I am not available and nobody can replace me, there will be no service. However, we are looking for as many people as possible who can take over the service and take turns. I will start it, and I will try to lead it as often as I can, every day. But like everyone else, I work and I have my own constraints, so sometimes it may not be possible. We hope to find a few volunteers who could replace me, or simply join a rota. That is what we are looking for.

The ultimate goal is to have an online minyan available in all 24 time zones. Obviously, the time zones in the Pacific are mostly ocean, but there may be a few islands where Jews would like to have a minyan, and if so, we are open. That is the key word here: we are open. We are open-minded.

What makes you think a minyan online is compliant, when a minyan can only be held in one single place, makom echad?

The reason we believe a minyan can be held online is that, if you read the Shulchan Aruch carefully, it tells you under which conditions you have a makom echad, a single place. It does not say that you need to be in a house. There are four conditions. First, being able to see each other. Second, being able to hear each other. Third, being able to respond: when someone says Kaddish, it needs a response, so it goes both ways. Fourth, every participant must know that they are there to pray and to make a minyan. When those four conditions are met, you have a makom echad.

So why does the Shulchan Aruch speak of a place? Because when it was written, in the 16th century, there was no such thing as online, or Zoom. Had Zoom been known then, would the position have been different? My view is yes. We can, of course, only speculate; nobody has the answer. But if you take a functional view of makom echad, all you need is for those four conditions to be met. Nowhere does it say that the place has to be a physical one. It is the other way around: if the four conditions are met, then your place is good.

A place need not be a physical place. In the Kedushah we say בָּרוּךְ כְּבוֹד־ה׳ מִמְּקוֹמוֹ, “Blessed is the glory of the Eternal from His place”. God does not reside anywhere; God is not physical. The verse speaks of a presence, and so makom echad can be read as a presence rather than a physical place.

Think of a minyan in a field. Ten people meet and decide to say the morning prayer there. There is no building, but it is a makom echad, because all four conditions are met. That is really the legal basis. We believe there is nothing in the Shulchan Aruch, or in halakha, that forbids it. The question of Shabbat and Yom Tov is a different one.